How to choose an SEO company | Scott Nailon
Key takeaways

  • Know your goal before you talk to any provider.
  • Ask for a review of your site and compare the problems each one finds.
  • Walk away from guarantees, secrecy and providers who hold your accounts.

The right SEO company for a small business is one that explains the work in plain English, shows real results for similar businesses and lets you leave without a fight. Most of the bad experiences I hear about come from skipping those three checks. Here is how to run the process before you sign anything.

Before you talk to anyone

Know what you want. More phone calls? More quote requests? A particular service in a particular area? A provider can only be judged against a goal. Write down your three most profitable services and the areas you want work from, and work out roughly what an extra customer is worth to you. That number tells you what SEO could be worth.

What to check

Check Good sign Bad sign
Examples Case studies from businesses like yours, shared with permission Only big brand names or screenshots with no context
Explanation They describe the work without jargon Buzzwords and mystery
Contract Monthly or short terms, you own your accounts Long lock-ins and control of your site held by them
Reporting Enquiries and revenue, not only rankings A pile of charts and no explanation
Links They explain how links are earned “Proprietary network” or bulk packages
People You know who does the work Salespeople promise, unnamed staff deliver

The conversation to have

Ask them to explain, in a few sentences, what they would do for your business in the first three months. Ask what they would not do. A good provider will say no to some things and will explain why. Ask what happens if results are slow. The honest answer includes what they will check and change, not a refund promise they cannot support.

Do a test

Ask for a short review of your site and the three biggest problems they see. A good provider will find real ones and tell you how to fix them, whether or not you hire them. If the review is generic, or every finding is a reason to buy their package, that tells you how the relationship will go.

Walk away if

  • They guarantee a ranking
  • They will not say what they will do each month
  • They hold your website or accounts hostage
  • The pitch is mostly fear about your current site
  • Pricing changes depending on how keen you seem

Agency, freelancer or do it in-house?

Option Good for Watch for
Agency Larger scope, several skills under one roof Handed to a junior after the sale
Freelancer or consultant Direct access to the person doing the work Capacity, and what happens if they are away
In-house Businesses with time and an interest in learning it Slow progress without experience

Questions people ask

Should I pick the cheapest?

Not on price alone. Compare the scope, the reporting and who does the work. Very low prices usually mean templated tasks.

Do I need to be local to my SEO company?

No, but they should understand your market and be easy to reach.

Can I check their own rankings?

Yes, and it is worth a look. It is not a perfect test, because the best consultants are sometimes too busy to promote themselves, but a business that sells SEO and has done nothing for its own site is worth questioning.

Read what proper SEO services include, or see my approach.

Written by Scott Nailon

Web and digital consultant in Sydney with more than 20 years in web design, hosting and SEO. I help small businesses get found and use AI where it saves time. More about me

More from the blog

Need a hand with your website?

Tell me what you are working on and I will point you in the right direction.